Comparative Analysis of ECN vs. Market Maker Forex Brokers for Scalpers

Scalping is a trading strategy which aims to gain small profits from multiple fast trades. Such strategy requires high precision, speed, and favorable trading conditions, and thus the selection of Forex broker is of crucial importance for scalpers. Among different types of brokers, there are two basic models, ECN and Market Maker, which can differ dramatically in their characteristics, thus having a strong influence on a scalper’s experience and success.

Electronic communication network brokers are able to link traders directly to the market. It accumulates quotes from different liquidity providers to make sure competitive pricing with tight spreads. Scalpers will definitely have much to enjoy since the spread is kept very tight, which helps bring the cost of entry and exit to its minimal rate. Also, ECN brokers provide transparent information on the depth of the market, which allows scalpers to clearly see buy and sell orders. This is a large advantage for people using real-time data in order to make split-second decisions.

Image Source: Pixabay

Another area in which ECN brokers have really excelled is execution speed. Scalping requires rapidly executed orders to capture minute shifts in price. ECN brokers, using their direct market access, normally execute orders faster with less slippage. This can be the difference between heaven and hell when trades are executed in a matter of seconds. The downside of these advantages are that most ECN brokers charge a commission per trade, which can become very costly for scalpers trading a high number of trades every day.

Market Makers function differently. Instead of linking traders to the market at large, they act as counterparties to their customers’ trades. This means when a scalper buys, the broker is selling and vice versa. The one advantage this model offers is no commission fees since the Market Maker usually makes their money on the spread. This would be attractive to scalpers who value cheap trading.

However, Market Makers generally have wider spreads as compared to ECN brokers, which can be considered a disadvantage for scalpers focusing on small price changes. Another potential issue is a conflict of interest since a broker may gain from his trader’s loss. With proper practices, genuine Forex brokers avoid such circumstances. It is a matter that scalpers must take note of when choosing a suitable platform.

Another is in the trading environment that each of these types of brokers gives. ECN brokers generally provide a more dynamic and competitive environment because the prices are affected by various liquidity providers. Market Makers can make the environment stable because fixed spreads are applied, and this can attract scalpers that need to see a more stable environment while volatility hits the markets. Mostly it depends on the personal preferences and needs of the individual trader.

Both the ECN and Market Maker brokers are suitable for scalpers with modern charting technologies, bespoke platforms, and risk management facilities. On the other hand, ECN brokers have raw spreads which most the ECN traders enjoy along with superior order execution systems. Scalpers who use high speed trading systems prefer ECN whereas simple setups are the favorite for market makers.

For any scalper, choosing the right Forex broker is pretty much important to optimize your trading strategy. The model of ECN and market maker has its pros and cons, and one understands the difference between the models that helps scalpers understand their trading style and needs.